Can I safely use an NTFS USB drive to transfer Xbox videos on Linux?
Asked by
MellowCedar42
I have an NTFS-formatted USB drive that I use with my Xbox to store screenshots, clips, and videos. I'm considering plugging it into a laptop running Linux Mint, copying those files over for editing, safely ejecting the drive, and then using it with the Xbox again. I wouldn't run games or applications from it. Some information says NTFS can be read-only, cause corruption, or have problems with permissions and executable files on Linux, while other answers suggest it works fine. Are those warnings mainly about running software from NTFS, or should I also be concerned about simply reading and copying media files?
Answers
If the Xbox accepts exFAT for screenshots and clips, that may be a better choice for a drive shared between operating systems. It avoids many NTFS permission and driver issues and works broadly across Windows, Linux, and macOS. However, if the Xbox requires NTFS for this particular drive, using NTFS for occasional media transfers is reasonable as long as you eject it properly and keep another copy of anything important.
Reply to this answer
The biggest caveat is Windows compatibility. Don’t access an NTFS drive from Linux while Windows has left it hibernated or enabled with Fast Startup, because the filesystem may still be marked as in use. Shut Windows down fully before sharing the drive. Linux repair tools exist, but Windows’ chkdsk is usually the more reliable option if the filesystem does become damaged.
Reply to this answer
For this use case, you should generally be fine. Modern Linux distributions can read and write NTFS, especially with the ntfs-3g driver or the newer NTFS support available on many systems. The main problems tend to involve running games or applications from NTFS, since Linux permissions, executable flags, and case sensitivity don’t map cleanly to the filesystem. Copying screenshots and videos is much simpler. Just let transfers finish and safely unmount or eject the drive before unplugging it.
Reply to this answer
The warnings about NTFS being unsuitable on Linux are mostly about using it as a native Linux filesystem or installing and running games from it. For ordinary photos, videos, and documents, reading and writing files between Linux and Windows is a common use case. Linux Mint may need an NTFS support package installed, but once the drive mounts normally, copying media files should not be a problem.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
Related Discussions