I've heard that enterprises shouldn't use NTP Pool and should use NTS instead. Are those actually alternatives, and what should a business look for in a time source?
Is NTP Pool good enough for enterprise use, and does NTS replace it?
Answers
NTS doesn't replace NTP. It's a security extension that authenticates NTP traffic, making it harder for an attacker to feed clients forged time. It isn't about keeping the current time secret.
You still need NTP servers, and both the client and the chosen servers need to support NTS if you want to use it.
Reply to this answer
The pool isn't a single service run by one kind of operator. It includes servers from a range of organizations, but server quality and availability can vary. Some people also remember periods when the quality was less consistent.
Whether it's suitable depends on your accuracy and availability needs, your tolerance for variable operators, and whether you need a support agreement. Calling it enterprise grade or not doesn't settle any of those questions.
Reply to this answer
For a more demanding setup, look at the whole chain rather than just the server addresses. Several sources may still depend on the same upstream clock, so apparent redundancy can be misleading.
Depending on the requirement, you might mix independent external feeds with a dedicated local time server using a satellite receiver. That takes more care and equipment than pointing clients at a pool, though.
2v!nexrali_683:
So several configured servers don't necessarily mean several independent sources of time?
Reply to this answer
Check the client side before putting NTS in a policy. Support depends on the time service you're running, so you may need different software on some systems. A security requirement isn't much use if the clients can't actually meet it.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
2k!ferrulebutton_583:
That distinction matters for requirements too. A reliable time source and authenticated time are related concerns, but one doesn't automatically provide the other.