Is the RX 9070 GRE a worthwhile upgrade from an RTX 3060, or should I get the 9070 XT?
Asked by
MellowCedar42
I'm building my first PC and recently bought an RX 9070 GRE after learning that AMD offers competitive alternatives to Nvidia GPUs. Afterward, I noticed reviews often criticize the GRE's value compared with the RX 9070 and RX 9070 XT. Since my current reference point is an RTX 3060 with 12GB of VRAM and I'm mainly aiming for a steady 60 FPS, is the 9070 GRE still a major upgrade? Would it be worth returning it and paying about $180 more for the 9070 XT? I paid $570 for the GRE, though a trade-in would reduce my effective cost to around $390.
Answers
At around $470–$480, the GRE can be a good deal. At $570, it looks much less attractive unless the trade-in brings your actual cost down significantly. Check the prices of the RX 9070 and 9070 XT after discounts, then decide whether the extra performance is worth the additional cash for your 60-FPS target.
Reply to this answer
The 9070 GRE is a huge performance jump over the RTX 3060—roughly around twice as fast in many situations—so it definitely isn’t a bad upgrade by itself. The criticism is mostly about value: the regular 9070 and especially the 9070 XT can offer better performance per dollar. Whether changing cards makes sense depends on the actual price difference and the games and resolution you use.
Reply to this answer
VRAM capacity alone doesn’t determine GPU performance. Two cards can both have 12GB and perform very differently, so benchmark comparisons are more useful than matching memory size. The GRE should still be a substantial upgrade from the 3060, while the XT is mainly worth the extra money if you want higher settings, higher resolutions, or more headroom for future games.
Reply to this answer
Compare the cheapest GRE and XT available where you live. If the difference is about $180, the XT will provide more performance, but it may not be necessary if your target is only 60 FPS. The GRE can be a sensible choice if you’re gaming at 1080p, have a weaker processor, or don’t have much room in your power supply and budget.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
MellowCedar42: That makes sense. I’m going to look more closely at my system and the real-world price difference before deciding whether to return it.