Is upgrading from an RTX 5070 to an RX 9070 XT worth it?
Asked by
MellowPine42
I'm new to building PCs and currently have an RTX 5070. I'm considering upgrading to an RX 9070 XT, possibly an ASUS model, but I'm not sure whether the performance increase is worthwhile or whether I should choose a different version. Is there any meaningful difference between ASUS and AMD-branded cards, and what has been your experience with the RX 9070 XT? I'd appreciate advice on performance, cooler quality, compatibility, and whether upgrading from my current GPU makes sense.
Answers
I'd choose the least expensive model from a reputable retailer that fits your case and has the power connectors your power supply supports. A three-fan cooler is often a good choice for lower temperatures and noise, but check the card's length and thickness before buying. Factory “OC” labels usually only amount to a tiny performance difference, so they shouldn't justify paying much more.
Reply to this answer
I wouldn't upgrade from an RTX 5070 to an RX 9070 XT unless you can sell the 5070 for a very good price or specifically need more VRAM and rasterized gaming performance. The 9070 XT is faster, but the typical improvement is only around 20–25%, which may not feel significant for the cost. Your 5070 also keeps NVIDIA features such as DLSS and related ray-tracing technologies, so this would be more of a side-grade with a moderate performance boost than a dramatic upgrade.
Reply to this answer
The GPU chip in every RX 9070 XT comes from AMD. ASUS, XFX, Sapphire, PowerColor, and other brands are board partners that add their own circuit board design, cooler, factory tuning, and warranty support. AMD generally doesn't sell a separate consumer-branded reference RX 9070 XT, so the important comparison is between partner models rather than “ASUS versus AMD.” In practice, performance is usually within a few percentage points. Cooler quality, noise, size, price, and warranty matter more.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
MellowPine42: That makes sense. I was expecting a much bigger jump, so I'll probably keep the 5070 unless I find a particularly good deal or start running into performance limits.