Some messages to Outlook and Hotmail addresses are bouncing with SPF errors. Could this be a recipient-side issue, or should I be looking at the sending domain?
Are SPF failures causing bounces to Outlook and Hotmail?
Answers
It could be either. There were reports of intermittent SPF rejection across different sending domains, including domains described as having SPF, DKIM and DMARC configured. Some messages got through while others bounced.
That pattern makes a recipient-side problem worth considering, but it doesn't establish the cause. Compare the bounce times and affected domains, then check whether newer messages are being accepted.
Reply to this answer
Start with the full bounce and the sending logs. Find the IP address that actually connected to the recipient server, then check whether that IP is authorized by the SPF record for the envelope sender domain. A valid-looking record for the domain in the From header isn't necessarily the one SPF checked.
Also check for SPF lookup errors or too many DNS lookups. If DKIM or DMARC is mentioned in the bounce, inspect those results separately rather than assuming they explain an SPF failure.
Reply to this answer
Don't rush to change DNS just because the bounce says SPF. Check whether the same sender can deliver elsewhere and whether failures are limited to Outlook and Hotmail. If the configuration checks out and the problem continues, keep the bounce details for a support case.
_h49+plivora.7:
So successful delivery elsewhere is a useful clue, but not proof that Outlook is at fault?
p.462!copperwinder:
Right. Different recipients can evaluate or enforce authentication differently, so the specific rejection details still matter.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
4r+ferrulewrench_527:
Forwarding can complicate that check too. The IP reaching Outlook may belong to an intermediary rather than the original sender.