I saw a claim that a newly installed router without Spanning Tree Protocol caused an air traffic control outage. Does that explanation make technical sense, and what can we actually conclude from it?
Could a router change without spanning tree really disrupt air traffic control?
Answers
Spanning Tree Protocol is a Layer 2 protocol used to prevent loops in Ethernet networks. A conventional router routes at Layer 3, so saying a router needed STP is not enough to explain the failure.
That said, a Layer 3 switch can both route and switch traffic. If the device had Layer 2 ports connected in a way that created a loop, missing or incorrect loop prevention could be relevant. The label alone doesn't tell us what happened.
Reply to this answer
Treat the reported cause as unconfirmed. A short account passed through nontechnical sources can easily blur the distinction between a router, a switch, and a configuration issue. Without a technical investigation, there's no solid basis to pin the outage on STP or on the installation team.
Reply to this answer
The size of the affected network matters too. A Layer 2 loop can cause serious disruption within its Ethernet domain, but that doesn't by itself explain an outage across a much larger network. You'd need to know how the affected systems were connected and what contained, or failed to contain, the disruption.
Reply to this answer
For routine changes, late Friday is usually a rough time to discover a problem. An earlier change window gives the team more time to investigate and recover with people available.
Air traffic control runs around the clock, though. If equipment is failing, waiting until Monday may not be the safer choice. The reason for the change and the available support matter more than the day alone.
Zeldavo+4x:
That makes sense. The timing might be a concern, but it doesn't tell us whether the work was optional or urgent.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
_n72!pluvexa.4:
And disabling STP isn't automatically wrong. Whether it's needed depends on the Layer 2 topology and what other loop protections are in place.