Reports say traffic from a newly installed Juniper router and another router overwhelmed part of the FAA network. Do we know what happened, and how could the disruption spread so widely?
How could one router disrupt communications at so many FAA centers?
Answers
The public description is still pretty broad. Officials reportedly identified a broadcasting feature that sent data more widely than necessary, and disabled it on the Juniper routers. Communications were disrupted at 17 of the FAA's 22 high-altitude control centers, according to the report.
That doesn't tell us which feature was involved or establish whether the underlying problem was installation, configuration, or the equipment itself. HPE said the devices appeared to be working as intended, while the FAA was still investigating.
Reply to this answer
A traffic flood can affect far more than the device that starts it if it consumes capacity on shared links or overwhelms equipment downstream. That can happen even when individual routers are operating according to their configuration.
But the missing detail is how the traffic propagated through this particular network. A loop, a routing problem, or some other forwarding behavior could produce a large amount of traffic. None of those is established by the description in the report, and a loop is not something you can conclude just from the word broadcast.
Reply to this answer
The bigger engineering question is containment. Redundant paths don't necessarily help if the same unwanted traffic can reach both paths or a shared downstream system. Figuring out where the traffic spread and what failed would be more useful than treating the router as the whole story.
8a~ferrulecrayon_592:
So a backup path isn't necessarily protection against the same traffic reaching it too?
_k49~zeldruno.5:
Right. It depends on how isolated the paths are and whether they share vulnerable equipment or control mechanisms.
Reply to this answer
I'd be careful about blaming the hardware vendor or the installer at this stage. A device can function as designed and still be configured in a way that causes trouble in a particular network. The report doesn't settle who or what was responsible.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
6j~quorlavi_372:
Also, the reported connection rate doesn't by itself tell us how much bandwidth was consumed or which devices were overwhelmed.