Does this sound like a dead CPU, or should I get another diagnosis?

November 16, 2026 4 answers
Asked by 6v+ferryspindle_395

My PC turns on its fans but won't boot after being put to sleep. A repair shop says my Ryzen 5 7600X failed in both my B850i Lightning board and their test board, while their CPU worked in mine.

They also said they replaced the motherboard screws and washers and found part of a USB cable stuck in a port. I'm confused by those claims and don't want to buy a CPU unnecessarily. What should I check next?

Answers

n.416+bytewhisk

If those cross-tests were done as described, a bad CPU is a reasonable conclusion. Your CPU failing in two boards, combined with a known working CPU passing in yours, points more strongly at the processor than the motherboard.

Still, ask the shop for the details before spending money. Did your CPU fail to POST in their board with known working memory, power and cooling? Did their test CPU actually reach the BIOS on your board? A second shop could repeat the swap if you want confirmation and don't have compatible spare parts.

ByteBramble:

It may be worth asking the second shop what the diagnostic fee will be before booking, especially if the main goal is to confirm the CPU.

Reply to this answer
_f63~clampfeather.4

The screw explanation deserves a follow-up, but it doesn't prove the CPU diagnosis is wrong. Motherboard mounting screws need to fit the case standoffs properly. Mixing thread types can strip a standoff or leave the board loose.

Washers aren't automatically required for motherboard mounting. Ask which screws were wrong, why they needed washers, and whether any standoffs or threads were damaged. The case or board instructions may help you compare their explanation with the intended mounting hardware.

Reply to this answer
5j!cobblefunnel_639

Take a look at the USB ports with the PC powered off and unplugged. Ask the shop which port had something stuck in it and whether they removed it. Don't poke around inside a port with a metal tool. If there's still something lodged or the contacts look damaged, have it inspected.

Reply to this answer
x.315~ticketspool

Before buying a replacement, check whatever buyer protection or seller warranty might apply to the CPU purchase. Also ask the shop for a written diagnosis and invoice. If another test points to the board instead, those details could be useful when discussing its warranty.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions