What makes you pick one over the others for an API backend? As traffic grows, how much do cost, performance, and operational overhead matter?
How do you choose between Lambda, Fargate, and EC2 for an API?
Answers
Traffic shape is a useful starting point. Lambda is attractive when requests come in bursts or the API sits idle for long stretches. With steady traffic and sustained concurrency, always-running Fargate tasks or EC2 instances may cost less, but there isn't a universal request count where the switch makes sense.
Run the numbers for your own request volume, execution time, memory, and expected concurrency. Include API Gateway or load balancer charges, not just compute. Also check current pricing and scaling options, since Lambda Managed Instances add another option that can scale to zero.
Reply to this answer
Check capabilities before pricing. If the workload needs a particular GPU, CPU feature, or level of host control, EC2 may be the straightforward choice. Fargate is worth considering when you want containers without managing the underlying instances.
Lambda has execution time and resource limits that may rule out some jobs. A browser-based report generator, for example, might be awkward to package in a managed runtime. A Lambda container image could work, but a container service may fit the workload better.
Reply to this answer
Don't count only the AWS bill. A container service brings image builds, patching, deployments, and task lifecycle management. Lambda handles a lot of event integration for you, which can make supporting services pretty simple.
On the other hand, a large collection of functions can become its own maintenance problem. The better fit depends partly on what the team already knows how to build and operate.
Reply to this answer
Look at what happens during a burst, not just average requests per second. Lambda can create enough concurrent executions to put pressure on database connection limits. RDS Proxy may help with that, but you'll still want to test the database under the concurrency you expect.
Latency matters too. Cold starts may be relevant for an API, and keeping capacity warm changes the cost comparison. Measure the endpoints that matter before deciding they're a problem.
Reply to this answer
It doesn't have to be one choice for everything. Fargate can run the main containerized API while Lambda handles event-driven supporting work. That lets each part use the model that fits without forcing the whole system into one deployment style.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
Tavrixo+6n:
Small workloads can also benefit from the Lambda free tier, so make sure the estimate reflects the usage level you're actually expecting.