I'm looking at LVM with snapshots for Proxmox, particularly on shared storage. What are the trade-offs compared with ZFS or Ceph?
How well do LVM snapshots work as a Proxmox storage backend?
Answers
Check the exact LVM setup and Proxmox version before counting on snapshots. The shared iSCSI and Fibre Channel volume-chain snapshot feature in Proxmox VE 9 was described as a technology preview in the discussion, not a fully mature production feature.
Reported limitations included offline export and import for remote migration and a disk size limit around 16 TiB. Check the current documentation and test those operations before building a migration plan around them.
Reply to this answer
A SAN is a pretty good reason to consider LVM. If the storage system already handles synchronous replication, replacing it with local storage plus replication could change how much data you might lose during a failure.
Work backward from the uptime and recovery requirements. Asynchronous replication can leave a gap since the last copy, and failover takes time even when the storage is shared. Ceph is another option worth evaluating for shared storage.
Reply to this answer
For a new setup without an existing SAN to accommodate, ZFS is attractive if snapshots are a major reason for choosing Proxmox. Ceph is also worth a look when shared storage is the goal.
There was some skepticism in the discussion about how mature the SAN snapshot features are. That doesn't make LVM useless, but it does make the specific feature set and recovery options worth checking carefully.
Reply to this answer
Don't assume snapshots are something you can leave in place indefinitely. The discussion raised concerns about nested I/O and recovery with LVM snapshots on shared storage. Test performance and recovery with the snapshot chains you expect to use, and plan how they'll be removed.
Reply to this answer
The application can narrow the choice too. The discussion raised SAP HANA compatibility as a reason to look at XFS or ext4 with LVM rather than defaulting to ZFS. Check the application's current support requirements for the whole storage stack before choosing.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
_p56+zavlori.3:
Also worth distinguishing that shared LVM feature from LVM-thin. They aren't interchangeable when you're checking snapshot support.