Our third-party email filtering contract is up for renewal, and we already have Defender for Office 365 Plan 1. Is the extra filter worth paying for, or can Defender handle the job on its own?
Is a third-party spam filter still worth it with Defender for Office 365?
Answers
Test what you already pay for before renewing. Set up the Standard or Strict preset security policies, check impersonation protection, and compare confirmed phishing misses and false positives against your current filter.
Also check connectors and mail flow rules for anything that bypasses filtering. A comparison against untouched defaults may tell you more about the configuration than the products. Keep the third-party service if the test shows a meaningful detection gap or it provides something else you actually need, such as mail continuity.
Reply to this answer
Don't assume Plan 1 and Plan 2 are interchangeable here. Some admins find Plan 1 sufficient, while others consider Plan 2 the minimum for their environment. Check the features and licensing against your needs before using a positive Plan 2 recommendation to justify dropping the gateway.
Reply to this answer
There's a case for keeping a separate layer. Different filters can catch different messages, and a gateway may provide mail continuity as well. That doesn't automatically make it worth the renewal price, though. Ask the vendor to show which threats it caught that Defender missed and whether its other features matter to you.
Reply to this answer
Factor in admin time, not just license cost. Defender can be effective with custom policies and Exchange Online mail flow rules, but someone has to maintain them and respond when a bad message lands. For larger cleanups, have a remediation process ready and look at whether APIs will be quicker than the web interface.
Reply to this answer
If you do remove the gateway, plan the mail flow cutover separately from the filtering decision. Check the MX record, any inbound connector that only accepts the gateway's IPs, and the vendor's SPF include if it also relays outbound mail.
Those settings depend on how your mail is routed, so verify the new path before removing the old one.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
Velnari.5q:
An API-based email security trial could give you another comparison without immediately replacing the existing gateway.