We're debating whether to route between VLANs on the core switch or send that traffic through the firewall. What would make you choose one over the other?
Should inter-VLAN routing live on the core switch or the firewall?
Answers
Start with what you need to control between VLANs. If they're just separate broadcast domains and traffic between them is allowed, the core switch is a reasonable place to route it. If you need detailed policy, inspection, or centralized logging, the firewall is a better fit.
Switch ACLs can restrict traffic, but check whether they give you the policy and visibility you actually need. Putting gateways on the core doesn't automatically mean traffic between VLANs is inspected by the firewall.
Reply to this answer
For a small office with a few VLANs, I'd keep it simple and use the firewall as the gateway. You get the rules and logs in one place without adding a separate routing design.
Check the firewall's capacity with the inspection features you plan to enable, though. Inter-VLAN traffic can add up, and it shares resources with everything else the firewall is doing.
Reply to this answer
For a busy campus or data center, the core can do the heavy lifting. For example, server and storage traffic may need more throughput than you want to push through a firewall. Use ACLs where they meet the requirement, and send traffic across a firewall where stronger segmentation is justified.
Reply to this answer
It doesn't have to be all core or all firewall. On a larger network, you can group VLANs into VRFs, route within each group on the core, and connect those groups to the firewall for traffic that needs to cross a trust boundary.
That gives you fast local routing without treating every VLAN as equally trusted. It also adds routing and operational complexity, so I wouldn't build it just to separate a couple of small office networks.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
q.471!claspfern:
That still leaves a security tradeoff for server and storage traffic. If it needs inspection, the firewall has to be sized for that load rather than bypassed just for speed.