An expired domain used for DMARC aggregate reports was registered by someone else, and reports for multiple organizations began arriving there. What could those reports reveal, and how should DNS administrators check for this kind of stale destination?
What can an expired DMARC reporting domain expose?
Answers
Start with the DMARC TXT record for each domain and check every address in the rua field. A destination should either be under your control or belong to a reporting service you still use and trust.
Follow any CNAMEs too. Several domains can depend on one shared record, so an old address there can affect more than you expect. Put reporting destinations and their renewal ownership in the same inventory as other production dependencies.
Reply to this answer
Aggregate reports can reveal sending infrastructure and authentication results for mail using a domain. That can help someone map out mail sources, although the severity depends on what the reports contain and how useful that information is to an attacker.
There's room to disagree about how sensitive that metadata is. It isn't the same thing as exposing mailbox contents, but sending it to an unintended recipient is still a security issue.
Reply to this answer
Don't assume enforcement prevents this. The reporting destination and the DMARC policy are separate settings, so reports can go to an obsolete address even while a reject policy remains in place.
Reply to this answer
Reporting gets a lot of attention during rollout, then it can become background noise. It still has value afterward, especially when a new mailing service starts sending for a domain and its authentication isn't set up correctly.
That said, some teams rarely review reports once enforcement is working. If nobody is using a destination, that's a good reason to reassess whether it should remain published.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
_c68!tramspool.5:
A third-party service can have a stale or expired domain too. Being a legitimate service when the record was set up doesn't mean the destination is still safe today.