Topgolf reportedly saved more than $11.3 million after moving away from VMware. What was behind the savings, and how useful is this as a model for other organizations?
What can other companies learn from Topgolf's VMware migration?
Answers
It looks like more than a hypervisor swap. The reported setup included VxRail, VMware, Horizon, NVIDIA licensing and Dell Wyse devices for presenting games at the bays. The replacement combined VergeIO, Kubernetes and a custom game panel.
That makes the savings interesting, but hard to apply directly elsewhere. You would need to compare the whole old stack with the replacement, including hardware, licensing, migration work and ongoing support. A company using VMware for ordinary server workloads may have a very different calculation.
Reply to this answer
Hyper-V is worth checking if you already pay for Windows Server Datacenter. The licensing economics can look quite different when some of the cost is already covered.
Just don't assume the management experience will be identical. One gap raised in the discussion was the lack of a direct equivalent to vCenter, so check what your team needs for centralized management before committing.
Reply to this answer
Proxmox and XCP are other options to evaluate, and cloud migration may make sense for some workloads. The choice depends on what you're actually running, not just which license costs less.
Inventory the workloads and dependencies first, then plan a move in stages. Familiarity with the current platform can be a real reason to stay put for a while, especially when the team has to learn a new toolset and keep everything running during the transition.
8f~gimbalnotch_274:
Migration effort belongs in that cost comparison too. A cheaper platform isn't necessarily cheaper in the first year.
Reply to this answer
For the bay displays, the Horizon replacement is the part that stands out. Moving the gaming workload into Kubernetes and using a custom presentation panel is a redesign, not a drop-in virtual desktop replacement.
If virtual desktops are your main VMware dependency, evaluate that piece separately from the server virtualization platform. Replacing one doesn't automatically solve the other.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
Ternwell-8z:
That makes sense. The headline number covers a broader change than just replacing VMware licenses.