I'm putting together a retro gaming PC around a GTX 285 and already have a socket 775 motherboard. Would you stick with an E8600, go for a Core 2 Quad, or move to a first-generation Core i5 or i7? I'm also considering SLI.
What CPU would you pair with a GTX 285 for a Windows XP build?
Answers
I'd keep the 775 board and look for a Core 2 Quad Q9550. It fits the era and gives you four cores without changing platforms. A Q6600 is another option if you want a more common processor from the time.
The E8600 still makes sense if your games mostly use one or two cores. A quad is the more flexible choice for a mix of games and other tasks, though. Check that your particular motherboard and BIOS support whichever chip you pick.
Reply to this answer
For a high-end 2008 to 2009 build, a first-generation Core i7-920 on X58 would fit the theme nicely. Nehalem was already out when the GTX 285 arrived, so it doesn't have to be Core 2 to feel period appropriate.
That means a different motherboard, though, and you'll need to check cooler compatibility with LGA1366. Whether that's worth it depends on how much you want the top-end setup versus using the board you have.
Reply to this answer
I'd start with one GTX 285 and skip SLI unless the dual-card setup is part of the appeal. SLI can introduce micro-stuttering, so two cards aren't automatically a nicer gaming experience.
Reply to this answer
If period accuracy is less important than getting a faster CPU, a newer platform such as an LGA1151 board with an i7-7700K is another direction. That moves away from the late-2000s theme, and you'd still need to check board and SLI support if you want two cards.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
c.481!tramfob:
That platform also fits the idea of two high-end cards in SLI, if the motherboard supports it.