What do uv check and ty's inline script support actually add?

November 17, 2026 4 answers
Asked by Tivlora-5n

I saw that ty is adding PEP 723 support and that uv has a new uv check command. How do they fit together, and what are the tradeoffs?

Answers

5v+hingecrayon_471

PEP 723 lets a Python script carry metadata such as its dependencies inline. The new support lets ty use that information when checking a script with ty check, and in IDE features like navigation and completion.

Separately, uv check uses ty to check a whole project or workspace. A new uv workspace metadata command passes project information between the tools. These features are currently opt-in and experimental, so the interface and behavior could change.

2c!gasketwinder_586:

So the script support is useful even outside a conventional project, while uv check is aimed at the project or workspace level.

Reply to this answer
_r84~hexling.6

I like the convenience angle. If you're already using uv and ty, a project-wide check command gives you one place to run it, much like uv format delegates formatting to Ruff. Shared project information could also make the tools agree on what they're looking at.

Reply to this answer
_z36+prismal.4

The integration is also what makes some people nervous. They may like the individual tools but prefer to run ty and Ruff directly instead of relying on uv as a common entry point. Convenience is nice, but keeping the tools usable separately matters too.

c.845!parcelwhisk:

There's also an open question about how accessible the workspace integration will be to other tools. The discussion doesn't establish what that support will look like.

Reply to this answer
_b93~mapcradle.7

Editor behavior is worth testing separately from the command line. One concern raised was overlapping language server features and competing diagnostics when using ty alongside Ruff. The tools can complement each other in theory, but the editor setup still needs to work cleanly in practice.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions