We're looking to move away from VMware in a secure area and are considering Hyper-V and Proxmox. Hyper-V looks easier to get through accreditation because there's a Windows Server STIG and the authorizing official is familiar with it. What else should we consider?
What on-prem hypervisor would you use in an accredited secure environment?
Answers
Hyper-V sounds like the practical frontrunner here. Windows Server has a published STIG, and familiarity on the accreditation side should make the control review easier than starting with an unfamiliar platform.
That doesn't mean the paperwork takes care of itself. Check the applicable guidance for the specific version and components you plan to deploy, then work through the configuration and evidence with your authorizing official.
Reply to this answer
Proxmox is worth evaluating on its technical merits. It uses KVM underneath, but a checklist for an underlying component isn't automatically a checklist for the whole platform.
Without a Proxmox-specific STIG, expect more work mapping applicable security requirements to the Debian host and documenting the management and virtualization components. Ask the authorizing official what evidence and alternative guidance they would accept before committing to it.
Reply to this answer
Take a look at Nutanix too. There is Nutanix STIG guidance, so it may be worth comparing with Hyper-V if the product and deployment match your requirements. Verify the scope and current version of the guidance before treating it as a shortcut through accreditation.
Reply to this answer
Don't leave the migration plan until after the platform decision. Veeam Instant Recovery and StarWind conversion are possible routes from VMware to Hyper-V, but test representative workloads, including appliance VMs, before scheduling a cutover.
If you're building a small failover cluster, plan the domain controller and witness placement as well. A two-node setup needs a witness design that still works when a node is down.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
_j94~stencilvalve.3:
That acceptance question is probably the key one. A platform can be technically suitable and still take more time to document and approve.