What should we actually want from automating jobs with AI?

November 16, 2026 5 answers
Asked by Varnelo-8h

AI can make work easier, but a lot of the excitement seems focused on replacing workers. If productivity improves while people still need jobs to survive, what should technological progress be trying to achieve?

Answers

d.486~sprocketpouch

Making tedious work easier is a good goal. The problem is that the person benefiting from the savings is not necessarily the person whose job disappears. A company can use a productivity gain to cut payroll rather than give people more free time or security.

That makes the distribution of the gains a separate question from whether the technology works. Shorter working hours and income support are possible ways to share those gains, though neither follows automatically from building better tools.

r.824~ferryruler:

Universal basic income is one proposal for that support, though people disagree about how it would be funded and whether it would be enough.

Reply to this answer
r.852~mapstaple

Automation did not start with AI. Software has changed or eliminated jobs for a long time, and it is fair to ask why some developers are more troubled now that their own work may be affected.

That does not make the concern wrong. It should make us apply it consistently to the people affected by earlier tools too.

Reply to this answer
4h+zunel.73

I'd separate automating a task from eliminating a job. A worker might use a tool to get rid of repetitive admin and spend more time on difficult problems. An employer might use the same tool to reduce staffing. Those are different choices, even if the technology is identical.

Reply to this answer
3n!velcroclasp_582

I don't think preserving every existing job is a good reason to reject automation. Removing drudgery can make useful things cheaper and more accessible, and there is no fixed amount of work for everyone to divide up.

That said, new work is not guaranteed to appear in the right place or at the right time for someone who loses their income. Deal with that problem directly rather than keeping inefficient tasks around just to provide employment.

Varnelo-8h:

That distinction helps. The hard part seems to be deciding who is responsible for supporting people during that transition.

Reply to this answer
_v29+sparelantern.4

The incentives matter here. Workers may feel they have to adopt new tools to stay competitive, while employers have a financial reason to reduce labor costs. Neither has to be personally excited about someone losing a livelihood for that pressure to exist.

So asking what progress is for also means asking who gets to make those decisions and who gets a share of the benefits.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions