A quick prototype can become a dependency for another team without anyone formally deciding to support it. Where do you draw the line between keeping it disposable and treating it like production software?
When does an AI-generated internal tool need production review?
Answers
Once another team depends on it, give it an owner. That doesn't automatically mean a full rewrite, but someone needs to understand what it does, decide whether it can be supported, and have time assigned to fix it.
Look at what happens if it fails. A dashboard people can ignore for a day is different from a script in a release or on-call process. The latter needs review and support before it becomes a quiet requirement.
Reply to this answer
Use the prototype as a working description of the requirements, not proof that the implementation is ready. Have someone review the design and code, add tests for the behavior people rely on, and check how it handles failures and access to data.
Review it like any other production tool if it is going into a production workflow. AI generation isn't the risk category by itself. Unread code, unclear behavior, and nobody available to support it are the problems.
Reply to this answer
Disposable can still be a valid choice for low-risk, low-value tools. Keep them out of critical workflows and make sure users know there's no support commitment. If people start relying on one for important work, the label won't stop them expecting a fix.
Reply to this answer
There's also a deployment problem here. If anyone can expose an unreviewed app to the company and give it access to sensitive data, a policy saying please review it later is pretty weak.
Use deployment and access controls to separate experiments from approved services. People need a way to prototype quickly, but company-wide access and production data should go through a defined review path.
7c!gimbalstaple_529:
That path needs a named support owner too. Approval without someone responsible for monitoring and responding to failures leaves a gap.
Reply to this answer
Don't overlook why these tools keep appearing. A pile of small scripts can point to gaps in deployment, monitoring, or other shared systems. Even if each one is harmless, the pattern may be worth fixing at the source.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
Ravmelo+7c:
So cross-team use is the signal to assign ownership, while the consequences of failure determine how much review it needs?