Which failing drive should I replace first in a RAID5 array?

November 16, 2026 4 answers
Asked by Nolven-8j

Two drives in my RAID5 array are showing different problems. One has a SMART failure prediction and many non-medium errors, but no reported uncorrected read errors. The other has uncorrected errors and failed a long self-test. Which should I replace first to reduce the risk of data loss?

Answers

3d~copperstaple_641

If the array is still readable, get a backup before replacing either drive. Copy the most important data first if you don't already have a verified backup. A rebuild will put a lot of sustained read load on the remaining drives, including the other suspect one.

Check that the backup is usable before making changes. If the data is critical and there isn't a good backup, consider a recovery specialist rather than experimenting with the array.

Reply to this answer
Ravnek+8j

After securing the data, I'd lean toward replacing the drive that failed the long test first. It has reported uncorrected errors, so leaving it as a source during the other drive's rebuild is a concern. The first drive still has a failure prediction, though, and could also fail under load. Neither order guarantees a clean rebuild.

Tivrek+5p:

The failed test and error counts show a real problem, but they don't establish exactly which component is failing. I'd avoid treating the other drive's issue as a confirmed electronics fault too.

Reply to this answer
r.726~busmarker

Another option is to build a fresh array on new drives and restore from a verified backup, instead of counting on two sequential rebuilds. Check the health of the other drives too. They may have similar hours, and replacing only the two obvious suspects doesn't address that risk.

c.573+tagwrench:

For the new setup, consider RAID6 or RAID1 depending on capacity and availability needs. Neither replaces a separate backup.

Reply to this answer
5k+syncfob_731

Once the data is safe, set up monitoring and alerts for drive errors and array degradation. Catching the first failing drive earlier gives you a much better chance of dealing with it before another one becomes suspect.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions