I'm learning Rust after using Python, and I'm confused about where the compiler's job ends and the operating system's job begins. Is the stack just a region of virtual memory that the program manages by moving a stack pointer?
Who actually manages the stack in a Rust program?
Answers
Yes, both are involved, but at different levels. The operating system and thread support set up memory for a thread's stack. The OS handles the underlying virtual memory and permissions, not the placement of each local variable.
The Rust compiler generates machine instructions that use that memory according to the target's calling convention. A function may adjust the stack pointer to make room for a stack frame, then restore it before returning. The CPU executes those instructions. Some values stay in registers or get optimized away, so not every local variable has a stack slot.
Reply to this answer
Think of the stack as ordinary memory being used in a particular way, not a special kind of physical memory. A stack pointer tracks a position in that memory, and compiled code reads and writes at offsets from it.
Frames can hold local data, saved registers and return information, but the exact layout depends on the machine and calling convention. Many stacks grow toward lower addresses, so reserving space can mean decreasing the stack pointer. Parameters aren't necessarily all pushed onto the stack either. Some can be passed in registers.
Reply to this answer
One Rust wrinkle: automatic cleanup isn't quite the same thing as stack management. When a value goes out of scope, Rust may run its drop logic. That can release a heap allocation or another resource, while the function's stack space is reclaimed separately by adjusting the stack pointer.
A Box, for example, owns a heap allocation. The Box value itself can be a local, but its contents live in that allocation. And heap management isn't simply manual in Rust. Ownership and drop usually handle cleanup without an explicit free.
Reply to this answer
There's also a virtual versus physical distinction here. The stack occupies addresses in a process's virtual address space. The OS manages mappings to physical memory in pages, so the stack's tidy address layout doesn't imply a matching contiguous layout in physical RAM.
Details vary by system. Some stacks can grow on demand when an access triggers a page fault, but there are limits. Running out of stack space can cause a stack overflow rather than giving the program unlimited room.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
_c79+quartzsifter.3:
So a normal function call doesn't need to ask the OS for space for each local?
2y~bracketladle_583:
Right. The generated code normally uses space in the thread's existing stack region. The OS may still handle a page fault if more stack memory needs to be made available.