I'm the only admin for 16 sites, and our Cisco Umbrella deployment is mostly using default policies. The renewal is expensive, and management wants to cut costs. Would a managed DNS filter or Cloudflare Gateway be a sensible replacement, or should I fix the current setup first?
Would you replace an underused Umbrella setup with something simpler?
Answers
Start by working out what the current deployment actually covers. A basic filtered resolver can block some malware and phishing domains, but it may not replace roaming protection for laptops away from the office, per-site reporting, or policies tied to users and devices.
I'd pilot a managed alternative at one site before cancelling. Check where DNS traffic goes, test the policies you need, and see what logs you can get. Also check whether devices can bypass the filter. A low block count alone doesn't tell you whether the service is useful or whether another filter will do better.
Reply to this answer
Before throwing it out, get a quote for a short configuration review. Umbrella may be perfectly adequate if all you need is DNS protection, and a few policy changes could make the existing subscription more useful.
Then compare that cost and admin time with the renewal and a replacement. If the price still makes no sense, you've at least got a clearer picture of what you're giving up.
Reply to this answer
With one admin and 16 sites, I'd be wary of adding self-hosted DNS filtering unless there's a good reason. Pi-hole or AdGuard Home would give you another service to maintain and keep available. A managed resolver is a simpler place to start if basic filtering is enough.
Reply to this answer
Cloudflare Gateway is worth evaluating, but don't assume a full Zero Trust rollout will be a quick swap for a DNS service. Remote access and on-premises applications can take extra configuration. Scope the pilot around the features you actually want, and check the current pricing and limits for your user count.
Reply to this answer
Don't overlook the firewalls you already have. Depending on their features and licensing, they may offer filtering that covers part of the requirement. Compare that with a managed DNS service before signing up for another large security platform.
Either way, DNS filtering is one layer, not a replacement for the endpoint protection you already run.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
_h65+pixelspool.2:
Worth checking the roaming client separately from office DNS. Changing the firewall's upstream resolver won't automatically protect a laptop on another network.