AWS added Advanced Hosted Zones with deletion protection, record history and public DNS fallback for $5 per hosted zone each month. When would those features be worth the extra cost?
Are Route 53 Advanced Hosted Zones worth $5 per zone?
Answers
The fallback is the feature I would look at first. Record history and checks before changes can be approximated with existing tooling, but building and testing a fallback for a Route 53 outage is a different job.
If a DNS outage would be a major incident for the service, $60 a year per zone may be easier to justify. Check how the fallback works and whether it covers the failure scenario you actually care about before paying for it.
Reply to this answer
For teams already managing DNS through code, this might be a hard sell. A Git-backed state file can provide a change history, and CI checks can catch unwanted updates or deletions before they go through. CloudTrail also has history of API activity.
Those aren't necessarily identical to the managed features, and they won't automatically give you the public DNS fallback. But if you mainly want a record of changes and some guardrails, your existing workflow may be enough.
Reply to this answer
The per-zone part matters. $5 a month sounds small until you have a lot of zones, and some people reasonably expect basic deletion safeguards without a premium. I'd total up the yearly cost across the zones that need it rather than assume every zone should get the same treatment.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
_x73+fendavo.2:
For an enterprise, the cost may be modest compared with the consequences of a DNS mistake. For a small setup, $60 a year for one zone can feel pretty steep.