Apple initially offered $245 for an older iPhone, then reduced it to $95 because the trade-in partner said the battery couldn't hold a charge. The battery was replaced at an Apple Store less than a year ago. Is an in-store trade-in a better option?
What can I do if a mail-in trade-in offer drops after inspection?
Answers
I'd reject the revised offer and ask for the phone back, then take it to an Apple Store for an in-person assessment. Bring the battery replacement record if you have it. You'll get a chance to see the offer before deciding whether to hand over the phone.
Reply to this answer
A recent battery replacement doesn't necessarily settle whether there's a charging problem now, but it gives you a good reason to ask for more detail. Contact Apple support with the revised offer and the repair record, and ask what the inspection found and whether the valuation can be reviewed.
Reply to this answer
In-store is appealing because the assessment happens in front of you. Mail-in can be convenient, especially if a store isn't nearby, but an unexpected reduction is a pain to sort out remotely. Experiences with shipped trade-ins vary, so a reduced offer alone doesn't prove the partner acted dishonestly.
Reply to this answer
Check other options before accepting either number. A carrier trade-in or private sale might offer more, though a private sale means handling the listing and buyer yourself. Compare the actual offers against how much effort you want to put in.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
2h!copperlatch_736:
That sounds worth trying. I'll check the phone's condition when it comes back too.