I'm currently using an RX 580 8GB with a Ryzen 7 5700X3D and a 1440p 180Hz monitor. Unfortunately, my current setup struggles to hit 30 FPS when gaming at 1440p, so it's definitely time for an upgrade. I'm looking at NVIDIA cards to make the most of local language models for coding, like GitHub Copilot, but I'm worried that 12GB of VRAM might not be enough for gaming or for the LLM tasks I need it for. In Spain, here are the prices I've found:
- 5070: €597
- 5070 Ti: €850
- 9070: €668
- 9070 XT: €749
Considering I game about 90% of the time and use local models about 10%, which GPU should I go for?
5 Answers
If your workload involves anything like streaming or video editing, I'd suggest splurging on the 5070 Ti, as it's far superior for those tasks. But if you're purely gaming, the 9070 XT might be a better fit; just keep the AMD driver shortcomings in mind for LLM use on Windows.
I'd go for the 9070 XT. For just €100 more than the 9070, you get enhanced ray tracing performance. Given how much better the performance has gotten this generation, the upgrade is worth it. Plus, it's great for gaming!
If you're after a reliable gaming experience, I personally love my 5070 Ti. It runs games beautifully, especially with ray tracing. However, the 9070 XT offers slightly better value for performance. Honestly, if LLM usage is crucial for you, the 5070 Ti might be the safer bet since it tends to handle those tasks better with more support in software.
Totally agree! The 5070 Ti is definitely more optimized for gaming and broader applications.
Realistically, all these GPUs will drastically outperform your current RX 580. They all pack a powerful punch; the difference comes down to your specific needs and future-proofing. But if you can swing it, go for the 5070 Ti—just make sure the extra cost fits your gaming/LLM balance!
When balancing pricing and needs, I’d recommend the 9070 XT or 5070 Ti. The 9070 tends to get overlooked, but it's not as solid in performance compared to the others. If LLM tasks are a big deal for you, you might want to shell out a bit more for the 5070 Ti, especially if you plan to engage in intensive tasks regularly.
Great point! 16GB of VRAM feels necessary if you're aiming for longevity with newer games.
I hear you! NVIDIA does have a huge advantage in LLM and non-gaming-related tasks.