Why is Authenticator asking users to set up another sign-in method?

November 17, 2026 5 answers
Asked by 7r!logicmaraca_395

Users are being prompted to set up face recognition, a PIN, or Face ID as another way to sign in. We don't have Windows Hello for Business enabled. What controls this prompt, and can we turn it off?

Answers

7q!circuitmuffin_583

First, check the registration campaign under Entra authentication methods. A Microsoft-managed campaign may be encouraging users to register another method. Review its state and targeting, along with the authentication methods policy, before changing anything.

Passkeys being allowed in the policy may explain the prompt, but the exact wording matters. A request to register a passkey is different from a request to unlock an existing credential with a PIN or biometric.

q.957+socketledger:

Also check whether a Conditional Access policy is requiring a particular authentication strength. That could affect what users are asked to set up or use.

Reply to this answer
3e~parcelnotch_814

Check the account's registered phone and text methods as well as whether those methods are allowed in the tenant. Some admins have linked the prompt to those settings, but there's disagreement about whether an individual account needs to have SMS registered for the prompt to appear.

Don't remove phone methods just to test this unless the user already has another usable method and a recovery path. Check both MFA and password reset settings before making a change.

Reply to this answer
_b73~canvasrivet.8

I wouldn't assume this is Windows Hello for Business just because it mentions a PIN or face recognition. Those can be used to unlock a passkey on a device too. Grab the exact prompt and check whether it's asking to create a passkey or authenticate with one already registered.

Reply to this answer
_n42!plumspool.7

There is a case for leaving passkey registration enabled rather than suppressing it. FIDO-based passkeys can provide phishing-resistant authentication, so the prompt may be useful if your organization is ready to support them. The policy and user rollout are worth deciding separately from whether the prompt is annoying.

Reply to this answer
Jorvilo-6t

Shared PC mode doesn't sound like a reliable fix for an authentication registration prompt. I'd check the tenant policies and the exact screen first, rather than change how the PCs are configured on that assumption.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions