Should I Use Separate Functions for Each Search Criteria or a Single General Function?

0
3
Asked By CodeNinja92 On

Hey everyone! I'm diving into back-end development and currently exploring SQLite with C#/WPF. I'm facing a design choice: should I create distinct functions like `FindById()`, `FindByName()`, and `FindByEmail()`, or would it be better to just have a single function, such as `GetEntry(string field, string value)`? The single function seems cleaner, but I'm concerned it might introduce issues or not be as straightforward as I think. I'd love some advice, especially since I'm still learning and figuring things out.

5 Answers

Answered By SQLMasterMind On

A single entry point for multiple operations can make unit testing a hassle and might not align with the SOLID principles of OOP. Keeping methods focused on single tasks helps in maintaining clean, testable code.

Answered By DevGuru77 On

It's usually best to go with separate methods like `FindById()`, `FindByName()`, etc. because they clearly state what each function does, making the code easier to understand. However, you can have those methods internally call a generic method like `GetEntry()` to handle the actual database logic. This way, you maintain clarity in the code's intent while also having reusable code underneath. Just be cautious with using a plain string for `field`; it's better to define it as an enum to prevent errors due to typos or incorrect values.

Answered By SyntaxMaster3000 On

I'd suggest keeping separate functions! Each of them will do just one thing, making it simpler to read and understand. If you use the generic approach, it could confuse future developers, especially if they call it with unexpected variables. Imagine how stressful it would be if they unknowingly use a field that doesn't exist anymore – you'd only find out at runtime. It’s definitely worth it to have clear and self-documenting code that helps avoid bugs later.

Answered By CSharpWhiz On

Both approaches can work, but having separate functions often feels cleaner and makes the intent of your code obvious. Plus, many modern ORM frameworks auto-generate these methods for you. If you write the methods yourself, stick to what you feel is most manageable for you.

Answered By DataDrivenDude On

It all depends on your application type. For example, in some research projects, it's great to let super users use detailed queries. However, if you're building something for students, a single input might be easier. It really varies based on your specific needs!

Related Questions

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.