I'm looking for reliable benchmarks for alternatives to ingress-nginx since it's losing support. Are there any good resources or benchmarks available that provide objective metrics on alternatives? Also, I'm curious about whether people would be willing to pay for a comprehensive benchmarking report that includes CPU/RAM usage and latency details. What do you think would be a fair price for such information? Any insights would be much appreciated!
5 Answers
If you're looking for an easy alternative, definitely consider using the Traefik migration tool. It's currently one of the simplest options available for transitioning away from ingress-nginx.
You might want to check out this GitHub repo for some benchmarks on the Gateway API. It could give you some valuable insights: github.com/howardjohn/gateway-api-bench.
Honestly, when it comes to performance, it really isn't as critical as some might think. If you have a good load balancer set up and can scale, the reverse proxy's performance becomes secondary. You should be focusing more on features and maturity when considering options like HAProxy, Traefik, or others.
When I first read your post, I wondered if ingress was really going away with NGINX's move. After some reading, it looks like migrating to Traefik is an excellent route! I have a Kubernetes setup that's a bit old—around 500 days—and I skipped NGINX because I preferred Traefik from the start. I think moving towards the Gateway API is the next step for me!
What do you mean by 'benchmark'? Typically, that points to some kind of performance comparison. There are a lot of those out there, but many of them have their biases or optimize for one vendor over another. The real value comes from a benchmark tailored to your specific configuration and workload. If you want something personalized, you might need to invest in a paid service and factor in the expertise of the team doing the benchmarking. Also, I noticed you're asking about free versus paid options—just a thought!

Isn't that more of a complement to Istio than a direct replacement?