Why didn't my Authenticator passkey restore on a new phone?

November 16, 2026 4 answers
Asked by _n68+gearparcel.5

I allowed synced passkeys in the work account authentication policy, then registered one in Microsoft Authenticator. After restoring the app backup on a new phone, the passkey was missing. Is that expected, and what's the best way to recover access after losing the original phone?

Answers

m.284!brassnotch

That matches the distinction in Microsoft's passkey documentation. The policy can permit synced passkeys, but it doesn't make every passkey provider sync them. A passkey created in Microsoft Authenticator is device-bound, so restoring the app backup doesn't restore that passkey on another phone.

Other passkey providers may support syncing, subject to your organization's policy. The policy setting and the provider's capabilities are separate things.

_n68+gearparcel.5:

So allowing synced passkeys doesn't change an Authenticator passkey into a synced one. That clears up the setting.

Reply to this answer
Nels

For a lost phone, issue a Temporary Access Pass if your organization supports it, then have the user register a new method and remove the old one. You don't necessarily need to force re-registration of every MFA method.

If the user still has another usable sign-in method, they may be able to add the new one themselves. Check your policies and recovery process before relying on either route.

Reply to this answer
zippity-6

Plan for the admin accounts too. A device-bound passkey is fine until it's the only usable way into an account and the phone is gone. Keep an appropriate independent recovery method and test the process before you need it.

Reply to this answer
_a64+hingebasket.3

Syncing is a tradeoff, not just a convenience switch. A synced passkey can be available on more than one device, but recovery and protection of the account holding it become part of the security picture. Some organizations will prefer device-bound credentials, while others may accept syncing for easier recovery.

_u59+ticketcrank.7:

And whichever option you choose, check that the actual passkey provider supports it. The tenant setting alone isn't a backup plan.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions