I'm looking for advice on setting up a simple office network that uses both Linux and Windows systems. My main requirements are to have common logins for all computers and shared drives. I've spent far too much time struggling with a Samba AD DC on an Ubuntu server, and while I got close, there's always something that breaks—whether it's related to DNS, Kerberos tickets, or domain groups. I tried following guides, but they weren't as straightforward as I hoped. Are there any good resources or tips out there to help me get this network running smoothly? Also, if anyone is in the LA area and would be willing to assist in person (for compensation), that would be great too!
4 Answers
Have you thought about using a QNAP or Synology unit? I haven’t personally tried them, but those pro/business models might be a good fit for your needs.
There's a specific guide for Ubuntu that you should definitely check out: [Ubuntu Samba AD Controller Guide](https://documentation.ubuntu.com/server/how-to/samba/provision-samba-ad-controller/). It's really important to familiarize yourself with the setup process before diving in. It's great to use an LLM for help, but having a good understanding of all the components is crucial. I've been doing networking for a while, and even I take the time to read up thoroughly before implementing anything new.
How many computers are you looking to set up in total?
You might want to consider using Windows Server for this. Yes, it's pricey since you'll need the server license and user CALs, but I've found Active Directory is way easier to set up on Windows. You can grab an evaluation ISO to test it out first. Just a heads up, if you go with Server 2025, keep in mind that LDAP won't work—you'll have to deal with LDAPS instead. If you're up for trying something different, there's a Samba AD package available on Debian, but be cautious as I'm not sure how updated it is. Another option could be Univention Corporate Server, which has a free tier. You'll need a Windows 10/11 Pro machine with RSAT to manage it, though, as the web interface doesn’t support the GPO editor.
Nah, toooo pricey.